How the hell is Cool Cat Cafe voted the best burger in Maui 5 years in a row? We came here for dinner tonight and I ordered a Jailhouse Rock (“juicy” burger served with sauteed mushrooms, grilled onions, and jack cheese) with no bun and a side salad. So not worth it. My patty was overcooked and overpriced and the cheese wasn’t fully melted on top. I hate that! Plus, you have to walk through all the touristy bullshit that is Lahaina Town to get here. On another note, you do get served by cute and tatted Madden brothers lookalikes so I guess that’s a small plus in its favor.